First visit to GardenStew? Learn more Already a member? -> Sign in     Not a member yet? -> Register


Is there a Starling Defeating bird feeder?


To hide these ads please register / sign in
Post Reply | Start New Topic | Register / sign in to view printable version of this page      




fish_4_all
Zone 8-9 Washington
Posts: 627
Posted: Tue May 04, 2010 2:33 am   Post subject: Is there a Starling Defeating bird feeder?


I have thousands of starling here and every feeder I have ever bought is emptied on a daily basis by them. I want to feed the wrens, wood peckers, swallow tails and the other friendly birds instead of these hoards of invaders.

Is there a specific type of bird feeder or a special type of seed to put in that will defeat Starling?

Also, I prefer to make my own so if anyone has mesh sizes or plans I would really appreciate it.

I know it is a lot to ask but is there a way to feed the wood peckers and keep starling away from it? special seeds/food for the woodpeckers that the starling won't eat.




To hide these ads please register / sign in
Back to top
Profile | PM | My Garden



toni


Administrator
Plants Moderator
Regular Plants Contributor

North Texas, Zone 8a
Posts: 14901
Posted: Tue May 04, 2010 3:05 am   


I only feed Safflower seeds. The Grackles, Starlings and Squirrels do not eat it so the Sparrows, House Finch, Red Wings, Cardinals and Doves get to feed to their hearts content.

Back to top
Profile | PM | My Garden | My Blog



eileen


Forum Moderator

Scotland
Posts: 22732
Posted: Tue May 04, 2010 8:57 am   


I have the same problem with starlings. I can't tell you how to get rid of them but here's what I do. Starlings love fat balls so I put one out just for them. They then tend to leave the peanuts, nyger seeds and sunflower hearts alone and concentrate on it. I also make sure that my feeders are placed in the garden in such a way that it's difficult for the starlings to get at the food.

Back to top
Profile | PM | My Garden | My Blog



fish_4_all
Zone 8-9 Washington
Posts: 627
Posted: Tue May 04, 2010 3:45 pm   


Eileen, how do you mean? Where do you place them that heps defeat them?

Back to top
Profile | PM | My Garden



eileen


Forum Moderator

Scotland
Posts: 22732
Posted: Tue May 04, 2010 6:49 pm   


I simply hang the feeders on a feeding pole's 'branches'. The starlings find it hard to perch on them to feed so tend to leave them alone. The fat ball is much easier for them so they tend to eat that and ignore the rest.

Back to top
Profile | PM | My Garden | My Blog



Papa2mykids
Kentwood, Michigan
Posts: 156
Posted: Mon May 10, 2010 2:13 am   


Feeders without perches or trays will slow them down, but to stop starlings from feeding is to go 100% Black oil sunflower and or safflower.

Starlings do not have the beak strength to crack them open (grackles can crack sunflower).

Oilers also attracted the best varieties of birds. Birds will only go to safflower if nothing else is around.

Wrens, swallows, orioles and most neotropical birds are insect and fruit eaters (that is why they migrate). You wont find them at your feeders.



Oilers attract woodpeckers, finches, cardinals, jays, grosbeaks and many other desired birds.

Give it a try, then you can use feeders with perches and trays.

Ron

Back to top
Profile | PM | Website | My Garden



topekachef

Topeka,KS
Posts: 15
Posted: Sat Jun 12, 2010 7:02 pm   


I found that if I left the feeders empty for about a week they moved on. Then it just took a little while for the birds (the fun ones!) to come back to the feeders.

Back to top
Profile | PM | My Garden



Wrennie

Catskill Mountains NY
Posts: 645
Posted: Sun Jun 13, 2010 1:54 pm   


You can make a "cage" out of chicken wire. Make it wide enough so that the starlings can't sit on the outside and reach in. The smaller birds will hop inside the cage no problem and get to the food.
To attract wrens you can buy dry or live mealworms at good wild bird stores to offer and put out suet. They do come to my feeders. Orioles, if you get the feeders out early will come to nectar feeders and grape jelly.
I also get catbirds at my suet. Not a typical feeder bird. And a thrasher this year.
Theres a small bird feeder called for clingers only by songbird station. Starlings and other perchers cant get on it. chickadees, nuthatches , woodpeckers can cling to its side.
This page gives some pictures of starling proof feeder ideas; http://wdfw.wa.gov/wlm/living/starlings.htm

Back to top
Profile | PM | My Garden

To hide these ads
please register / sign in


Join GardenStew for free today!



Ways to share this page (copy and paste codes):
Simple link:
Forums:
HTML:






     Sponsored Links