Bookmark us Already a member? -> Sign in     Not a member yet? -> Register


Let me in!
in Member's Gallery
last post: kuntrygal

There's a Deer at the window!
in Member's Gallery
last post: Calomaar

Empty yard, not for long!
in Fruit and Veg Gardening
last post: glendann

Peanuts
in Fruit and Veg Gardening
last post: glendann

Growing now
in Fruit and Veg Gardening
last post: newgrow


What To Do With Bean Plant Roots



Summer Garden Retrospective
bethie's blog
in continuation....
greenfairy's blog
New Yard and Garden
dooley's blog
Nice Weather And Yard Work
EileenT's blog


Droopy's Garden
comment added
Capt Kirk's Garden
photo added
scarthee's Garden
'what's happening' updated





Sjoerd
Enlightened One
Enlightened One

Joined: 11 Apr 2006
Location: West - Friesland
Posts: 2701
PlantStew: 93
Posted: Tue Sep 16, 2008 9:50 am   Post subject: What To Do With Bean Plant Roots


Any of you gardners that grow veg have surely heard that you need not fertilize the ground where in you will sow your beans, because the bean plants "make their own fertilizer".
It is true that if you fertilize the plants with a fertilizer that is high in nitrogen you will only get a very leafy plant that produces few beans.

What they are referring to are the nitrogen nodules that form on the roots of the plants.
The plants take in nitrogen from the air, process it and send it to the roots to form the little nitrogen fixating nodules of which I speak.
The plants then use these to "feed themselves" throughout the season.

The next thing you hear is that when the season is over, you should cut the foliage off and compost it, but leave the roots in the ground so you don't loose the "natural fertilizer".

This idea sounds good to me if you then plan to plant leafy veg like spinach, Swiss chard or the like -- something that is grown for it's leaves. However if you plan to plant other types of veg in that plot that do not require alot of nitrogen, then I have the feeling that I can just compost the roots along with the foliage and spread that out in other places in the garden after it has composted.
It is a nightmare trying to rake that ground with those little stobs of the plant's stem and the roots constantly hanging-up in the tines of your rake. Half the time they get pulled out anyway.

Well, while I was removing my bean plants and preparing the ground for the winter, it occurred to me to have a look and take some fotos.
It might be nice to see this phenominon if you have never seen it before.

Here is a plant just pulled out of the ground, It may be a little difficult to see the nodules.

A closer inspection shows them more clearly.

And finally an earthworm's view.


Perhaps not everyone has such an inquisitive nature as I, but it's one of natures' little oddities and bears investigation. I can still recall the first time I saw this and the feeling of amazement ind intrigue.


_________________
Sjoerd http://www.volkstuindersvereniginghoornenomstreken.nl/Page11.html
Back to top
Profile | PM | Website | My Garden
Question about Fruit and Veg Gardening? Register for free to ask in our forums.

Biita
Arctic-ally Challenged Forager

Joined: 31 Oct 2007
Location: Norway (Map)
Posts: 1834
Posted: Tue Sep 16, 2008 10:49 am   Post subject:


Very intresting! I usually take mine out each yr. But for some reason my beans and peas are not doing all that great. Altho it is the first yr they have been in this spot. The peas could be producing better, but the beans have been a disaster. I was thinking of planting my cauliflower in that spot next yr. You know the rotation thing for barassicas. What do you think. Leave the roots or take them out.


_________________
If you don't have faith in what you believe, then don't believe at all.
Back to top
Profile | PM | My Garden | My Blog | My Latest Blog Entry:Just One Day

cuatro-gatos
On The Way Up
On The Way Up

Joined: 23 Oct 2007
Location: Southern California
Posts: 66
Posted: Tue Sep 16, 2008 7:29 pm   Post subject:


I nominate this as a "Super Post!"

Back to top
Profile | PM | My Garden

gardengater
Knows Their Stuff
Knows Their Stuff

Joined: 30 May 2008
Location: NC
Posts: 915
PlantStew: 26
Posted: Tue Sep 16, 2008 11:20 pm   Post subject:


I never cease to learn from you,Sjoerd. I just wish my beans got that big. The drought finished them for us out here on the coast. I'll remember this for the future. Thanks.
Gardnegater

Back to top
Profile | PM | My Garden | My Blog | My Latest Blog Entry:vegetables

Sjoerd
Enlightened One
Enlightened One

Joined: 11 Apr 2006
Location: West - Friesland
Posts: 2701
PlantStew: 93
Posted: Wed Sep 17, 2008 12:30 am   Post subject:


Thank you, 4G. That was a really nice thing to say, but of course Frank makes those decisions.

Biita--I always follow my beans with brasscias. I know that caulis, for instance, require a dressing of sodium nitrate (NaNO3) after the heads (curds) have begun to form. I should say..."it is recommended" by some folks. I personally do not do this, but I like to keep up with other ways of doing things.

I am sorry to hear about your beans this year, GG...What kind were you growing?
There are ways to beat draught, you know.


_________________
Sjoerd http://www.volkstuindersvereniginghoornenomstreken.nl/Page11.html


Last edited by Sjoerd on Wed Sep 17, 2008 8:39 am; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
Profile | PM | Website | My Garden

Droopy
Slug Slaughterer

Joined: 11 Aug 2007
Location: Western Norway (Map)
Posts: 5058
PlantStew: 5804
Posted: Wed Sep 17, 2008 7:12 am   Post subject:


Look at those roots, how fascinating. Very Happy I love to learn interesting stuff like this, even though I might never grow a bean in all my life. Since I'm the lazy type of gardener I'd probably leave them in there.


_________________
The time you enjoy wasting is not wasted time.
-Bertrand Russell
Back to top
Profile | PM | My Garden | My Blog | My Latest Blog Entry:Christmas Show

Biita
Arctic-ally Challenged Forager

Joined: 31 Oct 2007
Location: Norway (Map)
Posts: 1834
Posted: Wed Sep 17, 2008 11:22 am   Post subject:


Ahhh okay Sjoerd, then i'm right on track in planting the cauli's there next yr. The ground should be full of nitrogen. I'll leave the roots in the ground until i plant the cauli's i think. I never give my plants nitrogen when they start to develop, because well there is so much banana skins and such already in there, i personally don't think they need more. Thanks for the help!


_________________
If you don't have faith in what you believe, then don't believe at all.
Back to top
Profile | PM | My Garden | My Blog | My Latest Blog Entry:Just One Day

toni
Mistress of Garden Junque


Moderator

Joined: 07 Jan 2006
Location: North Texas (Map)
Posts: 5698
PlantStew: 521
Posted: Wed Sep 17, 2008 1:25 pm   Post subject:


Thanks for the great info Sjoerd.
Our black clay looses nitrogen easily, every time it rains or the garden is watered too much so having some bean roots here and there in the garden next year will be a good thing for my purposes.

I would like to pick your brain over the winter about other vegies that I want to grow next year if you don't mind. 'Book learning' is fine up to a point, but nothing beats learning from someone who has been doing it for years.


_________________
"Blossom by blossom the spring begins."
Algernon Swinburne (1837-1909)

"A little Madness in the spring, is wholesome even for the King."
Emily Dickinson (1830-1886)
Back to top
Profile | PM | My Garden | My Blog | My Latest Blog Entry:Whatever pops into my head

EJ
Allotmenteer Extraordinaire

Joined: 10 Jan 2006
Location: Essex
Posts: 1612
Posted: Wed Sep 17, 2008 6:09 pm   Post subject:


Great pics there Sjoerd. Peas do a similar thing with their roots and I do try to leave them in. I grow runners in the same place every year as I dug a bean trench when I first took on the allotment and filled it with compost, shredded paper and manure so it isn't a problem for me to leave them in situ. A lot of people grow field beans on our site to dig in as a green manure, a sensible route if, as you say, you are planning a lot of leafy salad or brassica veg.


_________________
Check out my blog
http://allotmentnews.blogspot.com/
Back to top
Profile | PM | My Garden

Sjoerd
Enlightened One
Enlightened One

Joined: 11 Apr 2006
Location: West - Friesland
Posts: 2701
PlantStew: 93
Posted: Thu Sep 18, 2008 12:04 am   Post subject:


TONI--You are welcome.
As far as picking my brain, pick-away.
However, I can only tell you how I do things and I realize that my way is not the only way or perhaps not even the best way...but you are as welcome as can be to the experience that I have gained over the years.

EJ-- thank you. I use the same areas for my runners easch year too, the only difference is that I empty my trench each year and spread it out in layers in the compost bin. I re-fill the trench each year with veggie wasye, manure and paper. So each years' planting gets a fresh organic milieu to grow in.
I have grown runners under wigwams too, but that is alot of work and I must move those sites to rotate other crops through. Next years' spuds will go where the French and runner beans were this past year, for instance.
I think using field beans as a green manure would be a luxurious treat for the veg that followed in that ground, don't you? Smile

BIITA--It sounds good to me.
My cycle is beans-> brassicas-> potatoes...etc,etc. in the new garden.
p.s.--you mentioned banana peels. I knew that peels contain potassium and phosphorus, but I did not know there was nitrogen in them also.


_________________
Sjoerd http://www.volkstuindersvereniginghoornenomstreken.nl/Page11.html
Back to top
Profile | PM | Website | My Garden

arv
On The Way Up
On The Way Up

Joined: 29 Apr 2007
(Map)
Posts: 60
Posted: Thu Sep 18, 2008 6:26 am   Post subject:


You should leave the roots in the ground , Peas , chickpeas , beans are all leguminous plants which fix the atmospheric oxygen and store it underground . Legumes and brassicas is a good way to go .

Sjoerd (and others ) , lately I am getting really hooked up on no till gardening , that is no digging , no raking , planting amongst the remains of the previous crop . It builds up the soil and the various networks micro organisms , worms create in the soil which tilling would otherwise destroy . What is your take on it ?


_________________
36 cal/km commute
Butterchicken in Jerusalem
Back to top
Profile | PM | Website | My Garden

Sjoerd
Enlightened One
Enlightened One

Joined: 11 Apr 2006
Location: West - Friesland
Posts: 2701
PlantStew: 93
Posted: Thu Sep 18, 2008 9:22 am   Post subject:


Hello Arv--
I have been practicing what I call "min-till" for several years now http://www.volkstuindersvereniginghoornenomstreken.nl/Page18.html and I find it to be the best way to handle the soil based upon my needs. Min tilling is discussed a bit in this article on soil.
I do not always use this method in all plots however, as some crop sorts require deep and loose soil. I sort of tailor my treatment of soil based upon what will go in the plot.

I do firmly believe that soil, generally, should be turned and disrupted as little as possible. Having said that I would like to qualify this by saying that first one should have a good and healthy soil to begin with...and this might take some work getting the nutrition and structure the way you want it. After that, it's minimal tilling for me.
I believe that is is good to leave some sort of cover over the surface of the soil to protect it especially during the winter months, as I have posted a few weeks ago.

Soil is the very basis of any garden and it is good to read and try and understand it as much as one can so that it can be treated properly. The treatment of your soil will ultimately determine how things will grow on your plot.


_________________
Sjoerd http://www.volkstuindersvereniginghoornenomstreken.nl/Page11.html


Last edited by Sjoerd on Thu Sep 18, 2008 1:14 pm; edited 2 times in total
Back to top
Profile | PM | Website | My Garden

arv
On The Way Up
On The Way Up

Joined: 29 Apr 2007
(Map)
Posts: 60
Posted: Thu Sep 18, 2008 9:48 am   Post subject:


Thanks a lot for a comprehensive reply . Now where is the smiley for ::not worthy :: ( like in Wayne's World ) . Smile


_________________
36 cal/km commute
Butterchicken in Jerusalem
Back to top
Profile | PM | Website | My Garden

Sjoerd
Enlightened One
Enlightened One

Joined: 11 Apr 2006
Location: West - Friesland
Posts: 2701
PlantStew: 93
Posted: Thu Sep 18, 2008 1:25 pm   Post subject:


Hiyah Arv,

I ment to tell you that when we took over the "new allotment" the man that had had it before us did not till the soil at all...he just plonked things in and let them go for it.
The result was that when he moved on and we took it over--the sub-surface weeds and roots were rampant--no, "rampant" is too mild a word.
Things such as mare's tail actually do better in closed and compacted soil. My bride and I spent hours and hours cleaning the soil of pernicious weeds. It was a nightmare.
This leads me to think that strict absence of tilling is not a good thing, if you want to grow veg...and perhaps lovely flowers.
I do understand the principle, but the reality (in my situation, at least) is not practical. The competition for nutrition by the weeds wins out in a veggie plot ultimately. Sad


_________________
Sjoerd http://www.volkstuindersvereniginghoornenomstreken.nl/Page11.html
Back to top
Profile | PM | Website | My Garden

SongofJoy57
Showing Great Promise
Showing Great Promise

Joined: 20 Oct 2007
Location: Foothills of North Carolina Z = 7a & 7b (Map)
Posts: 732
PlantStew: 46
Posted: Thu Sep 18, 2008 11:54 pm   Post subject:


Wow . . . Exclamation

Back to top
Profile | PM | My Garden | My Blog | My Latest Blog Entry:Small Potatoes




You're looking at one of the many forums on GardenStew.com.
Register for free to join in the discussion.





back to top of page




Forum powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group


     Sponsored Links